Sunday, May 9, 2021

MICHAEL C. STEELE VS. JANE D. MCDONNELL STEELE (FM-18-0584-16, SOMERSET COUNTY AND STATEWIDE) (A-5172-18)

 MICHAEL C. STEELE VS. JANE D. MCDONNELL STEELE (FM-18-0584-16, SOMERSET COUNTY AND STATEWIDE) (A-5172-18)

Defendant appealed from a declaratory judgment finding the marital agreement (MA) she and her former spouse signed eight months after they married was a valid, enforceable agreement. And, she appealed from the final judgment of divorce (JOD) that incorporated the MA. We conclude the trial court erred by deeming the agreement to be in the nature of an enforceable pre-marital agreement. The parties' mid-marriage agreement was negotiated and executed after they wed, and the inherently coercive circumstances accompanying the making of the agreement here warranted heightened judicial scrutiny to assure it was fair and equitable. Therefore, we reverse the declaratory judgment and that portion of the JOD which enforced the MA, vacate the denial of defendant's counsel fee request, and remand for further proceedings. We identify factors the trial court should consider on remand when assessing whether to enforce the agreement.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.